Wednesday, June 10, 2015

Searching for West Immigrant Ancestors Using DNA Data

Compiled by Joy Ikelman, June 2015. This article contains theories, based on the author’s experience. All disclaimers apply.

Finding West Ancestors in the British Isles

Our Immigrant Ancestors
Immigrant ancestors are family members that first came to America (or another country) from a different place in the world. People with Colonial ancestry—such as West DNA Family Group #5—often have a difficult time finding ancestors “across the pond.” We may think that the best way to get results is to put the surname into a British database and forage. This might work with highly unusual surnames. It doesn’t work for “West.”

The Study Published by Nature Magazine
In March 2015, the results of a study were published in Nature—a peer-reviewed, scientific journal. [1] One of the purposes of the study was to compare DNA data with the historical timeline of migrations from other countries to Britain and within Britain.

Part of the study involved analyzing the DNA of 2,039 individuals. The participants lived in rural areas and knew that their four grandparents were born within 80 kilometers (50 miles) of each other. Historically, the data went back to about the mid-19th Century, before major migrations occurred within the British Isles.

Seventeen distinct DNA clusters were identified in the British Isles. This was a surprising result. The researchers discovered that people in the late 1800s did not often marry outside of their cluster groups. This implied that any particular cluster group might have been in place for many generations before the 1800s, especially in rural areas. This is called “partial isolation.” [2] The data were then compared with more than 6,200 individuals in Europe, to determine a deeper ancestry. The researchers were able to verify where British people originated in Europe or other locations. The data were then compared to historical records of invasions and settlements.

Professor Peter Donnelly, one of the researchers in the study, said:  “Historical records, archeology, linguistics—all of those records tell us about the elites. It’s said that history is written by the winners. Genetics compliments that and is very different. It tells us what is happening to the masses . . . the ordinary folk.” [3]

A Simple Analysis of West DNA Family Project Data
I decided to do a very simple analysis of the overall West Surname DNA Project results to see where Wests came from in the British Isles.  I used any narrative where a participant self-identified as having an ancestor in England, Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland, or Ireland. I used all pieces of information as “facts,” even though these might not have been proven. I was particularly interested in county names, but not every participant provided that information.

The overall West DNA Project (as of June 2015) has 347 participants that make up 41 Family Groups and 122 unrelated West lines. [4] Of these, 16 West Family Groups plus 16 individuals (who have no match yet) identified an ancestor from the British Isles. I plotted these on a map.



Distribution of West Surname Family DNA Project results in Britain as of June 2015. Family Groups are indicated by “#.” Individuals with no current Family Group match are identified with “W.” (Base map courtesy of Wikimedia Commons; attributed to Nilfanion and Dr. Greg, 2010.)


Although this is a very small database, it is significant. Looking at the map locations, you can see an interesting distribution with very few repeats. The locations are unique to certain West groups. The results were:

England
    Buckingham: FG#3
    Derbyshire: FG#31
    Herefordshire: FG#32
    Kent: FG#28
    Leicester: FG#31
    Lincolnshire: W135
    London: FG#8
    Middlesex (today in Greater London): FG#7, FG#24 [6]
    Norfolk: FG#29
    Oxfordshire: W54
    Somerset: FG#5, W154
    Wiltshire: FG#19 [7], FG#32
    No county listed:
            FG#1, FG#14, FG#16, FG#20
            W143, W200, W219, W242, W248, W279, W312, W325, W326, W359
Ireland
    Fremanagh: FG#38
    Down: FG# 9
    Leitrim: FG#9
    No county listed: W142, W205
Northern Ireland
    Armagh FG#9, FG#38
Scotland
    No county listed: W238
Wales
    None

The overall West coverage is similar to the distribution of the cluster called “Central/Southern England.”  There are a few West groups outside of the cluster area, including Wests in Ireland, Northern Ireland, and Scotland. Most of the West DNA Project participants have the haplotype “R.” These are probably descendants of the Anglo-Saxons who came into England circa 400 to 500 A.D. [7] Participant W54 has haplotype “J.” FG#29, FG#32, and participant W238 have haplotype “I.”

William West of Bristol, England
Debbie Kennett, English author of DNA and Social Networking, states that even the smallest clue to a town or county will probably lead to success in family history research in Britain.

“The chances of success depend very much on the size of the surname project and the range of lines tested, but if there is a match with a well-documented line originating in a particular town or village, your research will have much more focus and there will be a much greater chance of finding the link in the paper trail.” [8]

In Family Group #5, we have a documented line to Bristol, England. In 1855, William West (circa 1798-1902) migrated from Bristol, England to Sydney, Australia with his wife and children. His obituary in the Wangaretta Chronicle states that he was a native of Bristol. [9] Bristol has been administered by both Somerset and Gloucestershire counties over time.  

According to earlier family research (probably online), his baptismal record is dated 17 Nov 1798 and found in Kilmersdon parish, St. Peter and St. Paul Church, Somerset. His parents were John and Lucy West. [10] This William West appears on the 1841 (United Kingdom) Census, living in Kilmersdon, and working as a coal miner. His wife is Mary; they have two young children. [11]

However, there are problems with these data. William West’s wife was Elizabeth Jones. I have not found them in the Census yet, but by 1841 they had three children who were born in Bristol. [12] The William West in the obituary was described as a draper in Bristol—not a coal miner. He worked for Messrs Moses and Company, well-known clothiers. [13] A possible match for the correct William West might be one who was baptized on 19 May 1799 at St. Mary Church in Timsbury, Somerset. His parents were Richard and Mary West. [14]

There is a story among William West’s descendants that someone in the past did an in-depth genealogy that went back to the 12th Century, but no one can find a copy of the document. [15] So, we look for other clues to get started. In the Wangaretta Chronicle article, two men are mentioned as being from the same county as William West. According to census data, this county was Somerset. [16] This is an additional confirmation of West’s county of origin.

Narrowing the Search
As early as 1998, British genealogists worked with Oxford University geneticists to determine county locations of unusual surnames. [17] Here in the United States, we see “counties” within States in a different way. In American family histories, counties were sometimes brief stopping points for only one or two generations. In Britain before the mid-19th Century, rural people often settled in one area for many generations. The family might have changed parishes over time. [18] However, these are short distances compared to what we find in the United States.

For an overall search of FG#5 British ancestry, our starting point should be Somerset and Gloucestershire. These are in the Central/Southern England cluster group. I would also check Wiltshire, because of its location between the two counties. Devon county borders Somerset on the West, but Devon has a very distinct cluster group of its own, confined by natural boundaries. My opinion is that it is less likely that FG#5 origins are in Devon.

I would check counties in South Wales, such as Glamorgan and Monmouth, because of their proximity to Bristol. Wales is outside of the Central/Southern England cluster group. It has several distinct cluster groups of its own, such as “Welsh Borders” and “Pembrokeshire.” And, it is highly unlikely—though anything is possible—that we will find FG#5 ancestors in the cluster groups of Scotland.

We have two West FG#5 families almost ready to connect to Britain in the 1600s. These are (1) the Wests who first settled in Essex County, Massachusetts; and, (2) the Wests who lived in the Northern Neck of Virginia. [19] Early passenger lists of ships departing from Bristol to the Colonies might be a useful source of information. One such book, Bristol and America: A record of the First Settlers in the Colonies of North America 1654-1685, lists four Wests that came to Virginia from Bristol between 1654 and 1663, on different ships. Their names are Edward West, William West, Thomas West, and Francis West. [20] “Francis” isn’t a name in our FG#5 list, but the other names are intriguing.


References and Additional Notes
1. Leslie et. al, 2015: “The Fine-Scale Genetic Structure of the British Population,” Nature, 518, p. 309-314, 19 March 2015. The abstract is found online at: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v519/n7543/full/nature14230.html. Accessed March 2015.
2. “The UK’s Genetic Structure Revealed,” The Guardian: Science Weekly podcast with Hanna Devlin of The Guardian, and Peter Donnelly of the Oxford study, 20 March 2015.
3. “Genetic Study Reveals 30% of White British DNA has German Ancestry,” The Guardian, 18 March 2015.
4. Please refer to the West Family DNA Results page at http://web.utk.edu/~corn/westdna/
5. The Guardian, March 18, 2015.
6. John Frederick Dorman, 2007: Adventures of Purse and Person, 1607-1624/1625, Fourth Edition, Volume III; R-Z. Genealogical Publishing Company, Baltimore, MD. Middlesex, formerly its own county, is often cited as the origin of Anthony West who married Anna Huffe.
7. Edward E. Cornwall, 1906: Francis West of Duxbury, Massachusetts and Some of His Descendants. New England Historic Genealogical Society, Boston, p. 3. Wiltshire is often cited as the origin of Francis West who married Margery Reeves.
8. Debbie Kennett, 2011: DNA and Social Networking; A Guide to Genealogy in the Twenty-First Century. The History Press, Stroud, Gloucestershire, England, p. 27. Kennett discusses surname projects in England, citing progress made via DNA data. She also gives online resources (as of 2011) for research in England.
9. “An Old Bristolian’s Career in Australia; His Death at 104 Years of Age.” Wangaretta Chronicle, 25 January 1902. The obituary reports, “The late Mr. West had no documentary proof of his age . . .”
10. Verified at http://freereg2.freereg.org.uk. Accessed May 2015.
11. The 1841 Census of the United Kingdom. http://www.freecen.org.uk. Accessed May 2015.
12. Data compiled by the Leyshan family. Found at http://leyshanfamilytree.com/west/williamtree.gif. Accessed February 2015.
13. Wangaretta Chronicle.
14. Verified at http://freereg2.freereg.org.uk. Accessed May 2015.
15. Email from West DNA Family Group #5 participant (W338) to Kevin West, FG#5 researcher, August 2013.
16. The 1841 Census identified friends “Jacob Vincent” and “Mr. Nott” as being from Somerset.
17. Bryan Sykes, 2012: DNA USA: A Genetic Portrait of America. Liveright Publishing Corporation, New York, London, p. 73-93. Bryan Sykes of Oxford University is credited with the first application of Y-DNA data to surname studies in England.
18. Kennett, p. 25-26. “With the increasing availability of online records . . . it is generally a reasonably straightforward matter to trace a British line back to the beginning of the 19th Century. You might, therefore, find a baptism record in one parish which matches the age given in a burial record. With a rare surname it is usually safe to conclude that you have found the right baptism. But it is often easy to make false assumptions, especially if the parish registers for the neighbouring parishes are not readily available online.”
19. (1) Henry West (1629-1703) and his brother Thomas West (1630/1631-1720) first appeared in Salem, Massachusetts records in 1658. It is my theory that they were born in England. (2) Three likely brothers—John, Thomas, and Ignatius West—are seen in church records and land deeds in Virginia in the 1740s and 1750s near Falmouth and Fredericksburg. It is my theory that these three men were born in Virginia, and that their father or grandfather came from England. My theory is based on the history of settlements along the Rappahannock River. Falmouth and Fredericksburg were not settled until the 1720s.

20. The full name of this publication is: William Dodgson Bowman, N. Dermott Harding, and R Hargreaves-Mawdsley, 1929: Bristol and America: A record of the First Settlers in the Colonies of North America 1654-1685, including the names with places of origin of more than 10,000 servants of foreign plantations who sailed from the port of Bristol to Virginia, Maryland, and other parts of the Atlantic coast, and also to the West Indies from 1654 to 1685 : this list is compiled and published from their records of the corporation of the city of Bristol, England. Genealogical Publishing Company, Baltimore, Maryland, reprint 1970). Edward West, p. 54; William West, p. 65; Thomas West, p. 87; and, Francis West, p. 95.

Friday, April 17, 2015

Tales from a Civil War Prison: Reverend Doctor James Durham West - Archaeology Magazine Archive





Tales from a Civil War Prison: Reverend Doctor James Durham West - Archaeology Magazine Archive

This article is an interesting account of a confederate Lieutenant that was captured in 1864 and paroled at the end of the war and made an oath of allegiance to the United States Government.  His daughter said he was a good fighter and a good loser!

Reverend Doctor James Durham West is a distant cousin through our various West lines discovered through y-DNA.  Read the full article by clicking on the link above.

Thanks to Ben West for finding this article and sharing it with our West y-DNA family!

Friday, January 30, 2015

The West and Ficklin Families


Contributed by Joy Ikelman, 2015. Disclaimers apply.

Allied Families of West DNA Family Group #5:
The West and Ficklin Families



A portion of the map: A Survey of the Northern Neck of Virginia, being the Lands belonging to the R. Honourable Thomas Lord Fairfax Baron Cameron, bounded by & within the Bay of Chefapoyocke and between the Rivers Rappahannock and Potowmack with the Courfes of the Rivers Rappahannock and Potowmack in Virginia as surveyed according to Order in the Years 1736 & 1737. (Source: Library of Congress.)


Allied Families
As I was looking for data on one of our West DNA Family Group #5 ancestors, I discovered new information about an “allied” family—the Ficklins.  An allied family is generally connected by marriage. We may see these names linked to our family in legal documents, migrations, or family traditions—even if there was no intermarriage.


West and Ficklin Connections
Ignatius West was probably a brother to John West and Thomas West. Both John and Thomas West are part of West FG#5 through their descendants (DNA participants W270 and W299). West Family researcher Ron Roy did an extensive study of deeds and other records. He cautions that although the timelines fit almost perfectly, nothing is absolutely proven. This is why I used the word “probably” to suggest the relationship. 

Ignatius West married Patience Ficklin, perhaps in the early 1740s. Patience Ficklin was born about 1722. She was the daughter of William and Sarah Ficklin of King George County, VA. William Ficklin was the immigrant ancestor of this Ficklin Family. He lived on his leased property in King George County until his death in about 1756.

Between 1742 and 1746, brothers John and Thomas West lived in Stafford County, VA. In 1745, Ignatius West appeared in a legal record that referred to him as “Ignatius West of King George County, Planter.” In 1756, Ignatius and Patience were listed in a King George County deed, along with Ficklin family members. In 1770, Ignatius and Patience West were living in Stafford County. In 1791, Ignatius West’s Will was recorded in Faquier County, VA, adjacent to Stafford County. Patience is not mentioned in the Will.

In 1781, a nephew of Ignatius and Patience—Thomas Ficklin—migrated from Fredericksburg, VA to the area of today’s Lexington, KY. In 1784, another nephew of Ignatius and Patience—Edward West—migrated from Fredericksburg (or Falmouth) to the same place. I wondered if this was a coincidence.


The Northern Neck of Virginia
Where did the Wests and Ficklins live in the 1740s? I decided to narrow down the geographic region.

The blue rectangle on the map, above, is the result. The map shows the Northern Neck of Virginia—land that lies between the Rappahannock River and the Potomac River. The Northern Neck is only about 15 to 20 miles wide, and runs in between the two rivers for about 100 miles.

County bounties changed regularly during the 1700s. On the map you can see the boundaries of 1736/1737. Stafford, King George, Prince William, and Westmoreland Counties were north of the Rappahannock River. Orange, Spotsylvania, and Caroline Counties were south of the Rappahannock River. In the 1740s, both West and Ficklin families lived north of the Rappahannock River.

I searched for three places with Google’s map feature:

(1) Aquia, VA. John and Thomas West were listed in the Overwharton Parish records in the 1740s. The parish church was located near Aquia, Stafford County, Virginia. This church was about 12 miles northeast of Fredericksburg.

(2) Sealston, VA. William Ficklin’s land was located near Lambs Creek Church in Sealston, King George County, VA. This church was built in 1769 on the site of Muddy Creek Church (established in 1717). Unfortunately, no church records exist. The church was 12 miles east of Fredericksburg.

(3) Fredericksburg and Falmouth, VA. Fredericksburg is on the south side of the Rappahannock River. It is not in the Northern Neck of Virginia. It was in Spotsylvania County, so it is not written on the old map. Falmouth is across the river from Fredericksburg. In the 1740s, Falmouth was in King George County, but today is in Stafford County. The grandson of Edward West said his family came from Falmouth.


Migration to Kentucky in the 1780s
Thomas Ficklin was born about 1750 in King George County, VA and died after 1810 in Kentucky. He was the son of William Ficklin, Jr., Patience’s brother. Thomas Ficklin married Mary Herndon. “Herndon” is another one of our allied families. He moved to Bryan’s Fort (Lexington, KY area) with a large group of people from Spotsylvania Upper Baptist Church. (This Baptist Church was about 12 miles southwest of Fredericksburg.) Two of Thomas’ brothers also moved to Kentucky. Ficklin was one of the founders of Great Crossing Baptist Church in Georgetown, KY (1785).

Edward West (b. ca. 1730s; d. 1791) was the son of John West, who was probably Ignatius West’s brother. Edward was married to Elizabeth Mills in 1752. In 1784, they came to the area of Lexington, KY (near Georgetown). Most of their grown sons and their families relocated at the same time. He brought his nephew, Lynn West. Edward West owned a large amount of land in this new frontier. He was a gunsmith by trade.

I’d like to believe that the two families kept in contact in Virginia and Kentucky. There is a very high probability that this generation of Kentucky Wests and Ficklins knew each other. Joseph Ficklin, a descendant, was the postmaster in Lexington in 1828. Edward West, Jr. was a highly regarded silversmith and inventor.

Both families knew John Bradford, the founder of the Kentucky Gazette. Bradford was among the settlers at Bryan’s Fort. Edward West, Jr. lived across the street from John Bradford in Lexington. A West married into the Bradford family in 1818. There were probably business connections and maybe church connections between the Wests and Ficklins. But did they know their family connection?


Today’s Fredericksburg
All of the places mentioned in this article (including the References) are part of the Fredericksburg greater-metropolitan area today. Each is less than 30 miles away from the city’s center. What seemed so far apart in the 1740s is easy to reach today. A modern map that gives perspective is:

            Regional Map: Fredericksburg, Spotsylvania, and Stafford
            (Source: Greater Fredericksburg Tourism Partnership, 2015)




References and Additional Information
Ron Roy’s extensive research on the Thomas and Ignatius West is summarized in the blog articles:
        Ignatius West of King George & Stafford Counties VA
        Thomas West of Virginia
It is possible that most of the West deeds relating to Orange and Spotsylvania Counties are in near-proximity to Fredericksburg. As an example: In a deed of 1740, Thomas West bought land from Jos. Brock of St. George’s Parish in Spotsylvania County. St. George’s Parish was a land designation—today it is called Fredericksburg. In records of 1745 and 1752, Sherwood James and Ignatius West are mentioned together in lands of “deeds of lease and release” at Black Walnut Run, Orange County, VA. The location of this is near Rhoadesville, VA, approximately 26 miles west of Fredericksburg.

John West of Stafford County, VA and some of his descendants were addressed in my articles:
        John West (d. ca. 1744)
        James West (b. 26 Sep 1742; d. ca. 1780)
        Lynn West (b. 1775; d. 26 Jan 1836)
        Edward West (b. ca. 1730s; d. ca. 1791)
        Edward West (b. 1757; d. 23 Aug 1827)
        William Edward West (b. 10 Dec 1788; d. 2 Nov 1857)

Ficklin Family data came from various sources. The primary source (in addition to original County documents) is:
        Walter Homan Ficklin, 1912: A Genealogical History of the Ficklin Family, from the First of the Name in America to the Present Time, with some Account of the Family in England, The W.H. Kistler Press, Denver, Colorado.

Atlas of Historical County Boundaries. This site has interactive maps that show the changes in County boundaries.

The Ten Thousand Name Petition. The 10,000 Name Petition of 1775-1776 called for an end to religious persecution of Baptists in Virginia. It was signed by Baptists, but also by sympathizers of all faiths and non-affiliated citizens as well. The original has been digitized by the Library of Congress. In 1998, it was transcribed by Jean Pickett Hall for the Virginia Genealogical Historical Quarterly, in Volumes 35 and 36.
        Thomas Ficklin signed with other members of the Spotsylvania Upper Baptist Church. This was about 12 miles southwest of Fredericksburg. Today it is Craigs Baptist Church, Spotsylvania, VA. This is on page 87 of the original signed document.
                Edward West and Ignatius West are found on page 95 of the document. There is no church designation. However, sixteen of the names on that page (including Edward West) were original founders of Hartwood Baptist Church (in 1771) of Stafford County. The church was located about seven miles northwest of Fredericksburg. Unfortunately, in 1778, West was excommunicated from his church “for holding erroneous doctrines.” Hartwood Church was founded by former members of the Chappawamsic Baptist Church. Edward West and his family were members of that church in the 1760s.

Thursday, January 22, 2015

Family Tree DNA West Family Group #5

This is a summary of general information of each participant in the West yDNA test group #5 of the FTDNA West Project.  Each participant has been given a code identity to protect their privacy.  The summaries were compiled by the West Family Project Administrator.  Posted by John G. West, W64.

West Family Group 5
W22 and W23 match on 23 of 25 markers. They share one marker value which is somewhat rare, a value of 10 on DYS 385a, reinforcing the other information that they share a common ancestor. W23 has William West, b abt 1745 VA, as his oldest WEST ancestor. The earliest document found for William is the baptismal record for his two eldest sons in Shenandoah Co. VA, 1773. He resided in Rockingham Co. VA, where many of his children were born, before moving to Tennessee. He died in Greene Co. TN in 1829. W22 also has a William WEST as his oldest ancestor. His William was b abt 1816 in KY or TN, and lived most of his life in Anderson Co. TN. These families now believe that William WEST b abt 1745 is the grandfather of William WEST b 1816. W22 has added two generations to his ancestry through DNA testing. W24 was added to this family group on 14 August 2004 when his DNA results were completed. W24 and W23 match on 36 of 37 markers. Their relationship was known before the DNA test. W23 and W24 share a common ancestor, Samuel WEST, b 1836 MO, who was a great-grandson of William WEST, b abt 1745. They are 2d cousins, once removed. Genetic matches between known cousins reinforce the value of DNA testing as a means of identifying family groups.
   W42 was added to this group on 15 Feb 2005, following receipt of his DNA test results. His oldest ancestor is Charles P. WEST, born about 1780, VA. Prior to the DNA test, a link was suspected to the line of William West, b 1745, but documentation was missing. The DNA test has confirmed that W42 shares a common ancestor W22, W23, and W24.
   W46 was added to this family on 2 March 2005, following receipt of his DNA results. He matches W23 and W24 on 25 of 25 markers. The oldest ancestor of W46 is James O. WEST b 1808 in Logan Co. KY. This is a very exciting discovery for this line, because James O. West has been their brick wall. They are now working to determine the relationship to William WEST, b 1745 VA.
    W44 was added to Family Group #5 on 12 March 2005, following receipt of his 37 marker DNA test. Within this group, he has the most well documented paper trail to William WEST, b 1745 VA. His DNA results reassure the other participants in this group that some assumptions based on circumstantial evidence were correct.
     W59 was added to this family group on 3 May 2005. He matches other members of Family Group #5 on all markers tested, indicating that he shares a common ancestor with that group. His oldest identified ancestor is Robert West, born about 1834 in Hanover County Virginia, married Mary CLAYTON. Robert WEST was African-American, but we are unsure at present whether he was born in slavery. It is likely that his father or grandfather was a slave owner or overseer.
   W62 is descended from Claiborne WEST, b 1759 in Buckingham Co. VA. He was added to WEST family group #5 on August 30, 2005, upon receipt of his DNA test results. He matches W23 on 35 of 37 markers. A relationship to the line of William WEST, b 1745 VA had not been considered by either branch prior to the DNA test, so this has given them new clues to pursue.
    W64 is descended from Thomas WEST, b about 1718 in VA or NC, whose will was proven in Chatham Co NC in 1808. His DNA results were received on September 2, 2005. He matches W23 and W46 on 23 of 25 markers. A relationship to the other participants in Family Group #5 had only been suspected prior to the DNA test results. This group still has much work to determine relationships, but they can now collaborate to fill in gaps in their family history.
    W65 is the 10th member of Family Group #5, and was added on 27 October 2005 following receipt of his DNA results. He matches W23 and W46 on 25 of 25 markers. His oldest ancestors are Amos WEST, b abt 1766, probably in Orange Co NC and his wife Frances HERNDON. Quoting from the genealogist for this line " We in this West line have theorized that Amos West is a possible son of Richard West (b. Ca. 1738-1739, d. Aft. 1819), who is the son of Thomas West, Sr. (Ca. 1718-1808). Thomas West, Sr. is the ancestor of W64." This DNA results certainly gives credibility to their hypothesis.
     We are all very excited about the relationships being discovered for this group. In one message to me, W46 stated that he and W64 had exchanged information in about 1998, and concluded that it was unlikely their lines were related, so discontinued the correspondence. The DNA test has shown that they do share a common ancestor, and has re-invigorated their search.
     W104 was added to this group on 18 July 2006. He matches WEST family group 5 modal values on 36 of 37 markers. He is descended from Phoebe Smithers, born 1843 in Tennessee. Phoebe was not married, and gave her surname to her children. His DNA match, combined with WEST descendents of family group 5 living near Phoebe, appears to confirm that his Y-chromosome ancestor is from the line of William WEST/Mary Rutherford.
   W113 was added to this group on 5 January 2007. He matches W23 on 34 of 37 markers. W113 is descended from David WEST who married Susannah HOAG. The data and place of birth of David is unknown, but some of their children were born in Dutchess County, New York beginning about 1780, and later moved to Lewanee County, Michigan.
   W122 was added to this group on 24 February 2007. He matches the modal Group 5 haplotype 34/37. W122 descends from James W. WEST, born May 6, 1808 in Virginia, died May 6 1882 in New Liberty, Owen County, Kentucky. He married 3 times: 1) Nany NUTTER; 2) Harriet NUTTER; 3) Margaret ORR. W122 descends from his first wife Nancy NUTTER. James W. WEST was a blacksmith.
   W66 was added to this group on 27 March 2007, following completion of his 25 marker Y-DNA test. He descends from Judah WEST, born 1765, probably in Connecticutt. Judah married Mary TODD in 1786 in Colebrook, Litchfield County, Connecticut. Judah died before 1841 when Mary was probably living with one of her children in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio. It appears likely that W66 and W113 are from the same branch of this family that either immigrated to the New England area, or moved there from the Virginia area before 1750. W66 and W113 have values of 30 for the marker DYS 389-2, while everyone else in this group have values of 29.
   W257 was added to this group in June 2010. He descends from Benjamin WEST, born 1775-1780, probably in Caroline County Virginia, died in 1827 in Virginia, probably in Caroline or Hanover County. His wife was Nancy (last name unknown).
    W255 was added this group in July 2010. His oldest ancestor prior to the DNA test was Silas Mercer McLemore WEST, born 1826-27 in Alabama, and died between 1877-80 in Grimes County Texas. Silas married first to Martha A. BAZEMORE in Shelby County TN in 1853. In 1877 he married Mary DAVIS in Grimes County Texas.
   W270 was added to this group in October 2010. He descends from John WEST who died before Feb 12, 1745 in Stafford County VA. John married Dorothy (last name unknown), and they were the parents of James WEST b 1742 in Overwharton Parish, Stafford County VA, married Ann LYNN/LINN.
   W299 was added to this group in October 2011. He descends from Thomas WEST, Sr., born 1718 in Virginia, and died in 1808. He married Catherine Rebecca EASTINGS, born 1725 in Virginia.  W299 descends through Thomas son Ignatius WEST.
   W338 was added to this group in April 2013. His oldest ancestor is William WEST, born 1798 in England, died 1902 in Wangaratta, Victoria, Australia. He emigrated from Bristol, England to Australia in 1855.

Sunday, January 18, 2015

Cemetery Geek

Cemetery Geek by John G. West

What is a “Cemetery Geek?”  In the last year or two I had to research this term, since the Evansville Courier & Press my city’s newspaper labeled me a Cemetery Geek on the front page of the Sunday edition.  I remember some years back that being any kind of geek was considered not the best label.  I had noticed that the stigma was becoming less significant in recent years.  I believe that this change was due to the popularity of computer geek’s who could save the day for you when something went wrong with your computer.  But, do people think positively about a cemetery geek?  Too many people still look at cemeteries as a negative place to visit or even talk about.
This is probably a good time to define what a “geek” actually is all about.  A geek is somewhat obsessive about their generally single subject like computers, science or even movie series like Star Trek or Dr. Who.  Most geeks are sociable and outgoing (these parts I seem to possess a large dose).  Geeks are generally of average intelligence, but become very knowledgeable within their geekdom.  I suppose that one reason I was concerned about being labeled as a geek was because a few people thought of me as a “nerd” in my youth.  A nerd really got a bad rap over the years.  Nerds are smart people who lack much of a social life. They often have very few friends. Nerds don't talk much, and don't expect others to talk much to them. They are usually nice people, but don't have the social skills to go out and meet new friends.  Actually, nerds are very smart, intelligent people.  This was probably why the other kids around me thought I was a nerd… I was just too darn smart!  I generally have never been accused of not talking!  In fact, I have always been accused of talking too much!  Tell me how can anyone talk too much?

So, I guess I could be a smart geek, but a cemetery geek?  I know I am obsessed with genealogy.  I have researched my family history for over 55 years.  I talk about genealogy, I present workshops about genealogy, I have worked with people to help them learn to document their history.  I spent many years working with the 4-H genealogy project in Indiana.  Call me a Genealogy Geek.

Of course while researching my family history, I have visited quite a few cemeteries.  I was talking about how many cemeteries have I actually walked around to study and photograph tombstones or searched for relatives, etc.  I was able to name 78 cemeteries without notes or thinking about it much (almost all had family buried there or I had other special connections).  I suspect several were forgotten at the time, I have thought about two others since that day.  I feel like I could say that I have been in at least 80-100 cemeteries.  To me, cemeteries are places of serenity and a place to think about life.  Each grave marker is a monument to the person it records.  Often a little history can become known by the marker or a group of markers.  There are many, many different types & shapes of these grave stones.  The statues,  carvings and ornate sculpturing are so beautiful like an outdoor art gallery.  OK, I am a “Cemetery Geek” – I admit it.  I cannot help it!

I am also a geek of many other pursuits, as well.  Are you a cemetery geek?  If you are, let’s talk about our passion.


I am also known as Indiana Bones, a cemetery geek!

Tuesday, December 30, 2014

Judah West (1765-1825)

Wests from Middlesex and Litchfield Counties, Connecticut:
Judah West (1765-1825)

Compiled by Joy Ikelman, December 2014. Disclaimers apply. Note: The use of double dating, such as 1630/1631, reflects the difference between the Julian and Gregorian Calendars.

Background: Judah West (1765-1825) was added to West DNA Family Group #5 in 2007. [1] David West, Jr. (1761-ca 1855) and Aaron West (1763-1840) were his brothers. They were descendants of Thomas West (1630/1631-1720) of Essex County, Massachusetts. This is the last of six articles about the Connecticut line of this FG#5 family. This concludes my year-long study of the family of Thomas West.

Thomas West (1630/1631-1720) m. Phebe Waters
       - Benjamin West (1665-1733) m. Hannah Shadduck
            - Benjamin West, Jr. (1696-after 1739) m. Mehitable Bailey
                  - David West (ca. 1736-1822) m. Judith Hills
                        - David West, Jr. (1761-ca 1855) m. Unknown
                        - Aaron West (1763-1840) m. Susannah Kellogg
                        - Judah West (1765-1825) m. Mary Todd



Three Revolutionary War Patriots
Judah, Aaron, and David West were brothers who served in the Revolutionary War. They were the sons of David West (Sr.) and Judith Hills West. Their combined service spans from 1776 to 1783—nearly the entire war. Their Revolutionary War pension applications are a rich source of information on historical events and also their personal lives. Each of the three articles on these brothers includes a biography, references, and a transcript of the pension application. 

Judah West was born on 11 Sep 1765 [2] in Middlesex County, Connecticut. Judah probably grew up on his family’s land in what is today called East Hampton, Middlesex County, CT (south of Lake Pocotopaug). [3] There was another Judah West born in Connecticut about this time, so it is important to follow the correct family! [4]


Revolutionary War Service
In 1781, one month before his sixteenth birthday, Judah West voluntarily enlisted in the service at Chatham, Middlesex County, CT. [5] He served from August 1781 through December 1783.

Judah West’s pension application says that he served under Colonel Jackson and also under Colonel Sprout. He was in Captain Smith’s company. He was in the third or eighth regiment on the Massachusetts Line. There is some confusion on this. His pension application mentions the eighth regiment. His official discharge from service—included with his pension application—says the third regiment.

By the Honourable Major-General Knox Commanding the American Forces on Hudson’s River. Here may certify that Judah West, private in the third Massachusetts Regiment, being enlisted for Three Years, is hereby honourably discharged from the Service of the United States. Given in the State of New York, the twenty third Day of December 1783. By the General’s Command. H Knox MGen.  Registered in the Books of the Regiment, John B. Stafford, Adjt
Two secondary sources have other versions. A mention in Annals of Winchester says Judah West served in the eighth company, second regiment. [6] Massachusetts Soldiers and Sailors of the Revolutionary War (1896) says:

West, Judah. Private, Capt. Ebenezer Smith’s (Seventh) Co., Eighth Mass. Regt. Commanded by Col. Michael Jackson; muster roll for April, 1783, balance of term of enlistment unexpired, 15 months 18 days. [7]

Judah West enlisted in Middlesex County, CT but served on the Massachusetts Line instead of the Connecticut Line. Why did this happen?

The Continental Congress assigned each State a number of soldiers required to maintain a viable Continental Army. Connecticut was divided into districts, and a close accounting was made of all males 16 years and older. As an example, Middlesex County, CT, took care “that the old men, middle aged & young men, rich and poor men be distributed into each of the said classes equally as may be, & notify the same accordingly.” [8]

After the men were trained, they were usually assigned to the Connecticut Line. However, each State had their own system, and sometimes negotiated with other States to meet their recruitment goals. The list of Connecticut pensioners in 1818 shows the diversity of service. Judah is noted as “Priv., Mass.” Other men from Connecticut served on the Rhode Island, New York, and New Jersey Lines. [9]

In 1780, the Continental Congress (with General George Washington) reorganized the Army. By 15 Nov 1783, all the Massachusetts regiments had disbanded, and thus, the Massachusetts Line was no longer in existence. [10] Judah West was discharged in December.


The West Family Moves to Litchfield County, Connecticut
In 1783, David West and Judith Hills West, Judah’s parents, moved the family to Winsted (Winchester Township), Litchfield County, CT. Winchester was considered a remote area at the time. David West “first lived in a log house at the base of Cobble Hill on Spencer Street, a little south of the site of the Joshua Hewitt dwelling.” [11] He later lived on the turnpike (Main Street) in “an old house on the site of George Dudley’s residence. [12]

Judah, who was 18 years old, moved with his family to Winsted. There were six other children, ages 6 to 16, living at home. Judah’s older brother Aaron also moved to Winsted. He lived on Spencer Street, like his father. He was “a grantee of the Lockwood Farm.” [13]

Judah West “first lived on the Halsey Burr place on the old Still River turnpike” and then “on the east side of the same road where the old toll gate was located.” [14] Today, this is in the region of Connecticut Route 8 and U.S. Route 44. Judah lived there until his death in 1825. An inventory with his pension application stated that he had 20 acres of land (in 1818).


Marriage to Mary Todd
Two years after moving to Winsted, Judah married Mary Todd of Winchester. They were married on 26 Dec 1785 in Colebrook, Litchfield County, CT [15] at Elijah Rockwell, Sr.’s house. Rockwell was a Justice of the Peace. [16]

Mary Todd West’s birth year and birth place are not known. Her tombstone implies (but does not state) that she was born in 1764. Judah West’s pension application says it is 1760; her widow’s pension application suggests it is 1763. According to the Census of 1840, her birth year is possibly 1761. It was not unusual to be unsure of your birth date during those times.


Children of Judah and Mary West
Only the first four children are recorded in Winchester, Connecticut Vital Records. Fortunately for family researchers, another interesting record exists. A page from a West Family Bible was included with Mary West’s pension application. The page was in the handwriting of Hiram Wescott (who married Flora West). He copied information from Judah West’s older Bible to a new one (in 1821) at the request of Mary West. The original had been in Judah West’s handwriting. Wescott testified that it was a “true copy.” This copy was torn out of the Bible and sent with Mary’s application. [17]

The first copied entry is a child named Christopher Basset, born 6 Sept 1782. [18] Edgar West testified that:  

. . . I further state that I have always understood that Christopher Basset whose birth is first entered on said record is not the son of my said father but an illegitimate son of my said mother born several years before the Marriage of my said father & mother.

Mary West would have been about 16 to 18 years old when she had this child. We do not know the circumstances or the fate of Christopher. Nine West children are listed on the Bible page: Polly, David, Alpha, Nancy, David, Hannah, Edgar, Welthy, and Flora. All were born in Winsted, Connecticut, from 1786 through 1804.


Note: All census information below is from the Records of the Bureau of the Census, National Archives, Washington, D.C.  Images from the originals are available from various on-line sources.

1. Mary (or Polly) West b. 26 Sep 1786. [19]
        m. about 1806 Erastus Burr. [20]
        Mary and Erastus Burr moved to western New York about 1812. [21] In the 1820 Census, Erastus Burr and his family are counted in Butternuts, Otsego County, New York. There are two adults and four children. In the 1830 Census they have two children living at home. It appears from later census records that Erastus did not move from the area, but may have remarried.

2. David West b. 20 Feb 1789; d. 22 Feb 1790. [22] He lived one year.

3. Alpha West b. 4 Sep 1790 [23]; d. 8 Mar 1848; buried at Concord Township Cemetery, Lake County, Ohio. [24]
        m. Anna, b. 1792; d. 9 Nov 1864; buried at Concord Township Cemetery. [25]
        According to the 1820 Census, Alpha West and his family lived in Butternuts, Otsego County, New York. There are two adults and four children. Erastus and Mary West Burr lived there also.
        In the 1830 Census, Alpha West and his family lived in New Berlin, Chenango, New York. There are two adults and six children. His younger brother David is also listed in this Census. “Historical Sketches of Old New Berlin” mentions them both:

Alpha West and his brother David were among the first settlers in the neighborhood of the Swan farm. It was the custom then to have company trainings, officer trainings and regimental trainings yearly, and Alpha and David performed their military duties as musicians, making the wild woods ring with martial music on parade days. They too, went west a long time ago to seek their fortune in other lands. [26]

        When Alpha and David West were living in New Berlin, some West DNA Family Group #5 cousins were living in Norwich (in the same county) about nine miles away. [27] The cousins were Stephen, Ephraim, David, Talmadge, and Clinton West. They were descended from Samuel West (b. about 1659/1660). Alpha and David were descended from Samuel’s brother, Benjamin West (b. 1665). I’m not sure that the cousins knew about each other.
        I could not find Alpha West in the 1840 Census. In 1848, Alpha was the first of the West family to be buried at Concord Township Cemetery in Lake County, Ohio.

4. Nancy West b. 6 Sept 1792 [28]; d. 10 May 1850; buried at Concord Township Cemetery, Lake County, Ohio. [29]
        m. Roswell Burr (1794-1857), brother to Halsey Burr and Erastus Burr. Erastus married Mary (Polly).
        Children included David Burr, Luther Burr, Halsey Burr, and Roswell Burr. [30]
        In the 1830 Census Nancy and Roswell, and five or six children were living in Winchester, Litchfield County, CT. They moved to Ohio in 1833. [31] In the 1840 Census, they were in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio; no children were living with them.

The rest of the children are recorded in the Bible record but not in Winchester Vital Records.

5. David West b. 13 Jun 1794 [32]; d. 16 Aug 1878; buried in Sugar Grove Cemetery, Kane County, Illinois. [33]
        m. (1) 5 Feb 1816 Dorothy “Dolly” Phelps, in Chenango County, NY. She was born 13 Feb 1794 in New York and died 7 Feb 1831. [34] She is buried at Upper Phelps Cemetery in New Berlin, Chenango County, NY. Some of their children were also buried there. [36] There were “seven children, three living” (in 1878). [37] One was William P. West, b. 11 Mar 1818; d. 14 May 1886. [38]
        m. (2) 7 Feb 1832 Rachel Simmons Stoddard, a widow, in Chenango County, NY. [39] She was born 31 May 1803 in Winsted, Litchfield County, CT. [40] She married (1) Norman Stoddard of Litchfield, CT, 18 Apr 1822. [41] She died 6 Aug 1884 in Blackberry, Kane County, IL. She is buried with David West in Sugar Grove Cemetery. The monument says “Father and Mother.” [42] David and Rachel had five children including George C. West, F.J. West, Theron W. West, and Helen E. West Reeves. [43]
        David West and his older brother Alpha lived in New Berlin, Chenango County, NY at the same time. Please refer to Alpha’s entry. The entry also mentions DNA cousins that lived in Norwich, Chenango County, NY, nine miles away. Beatrice West Seitz, genealogist for these cousins, examined land deeds and included those for David and Dorothy West in her publication. [44] See the reference for abstracts.
        David West was listed in the 1840 Census of New Berlin, Chenango County, NY. David, Rachel and their children came to Kane County, Illinois in September 1843. [45] He was listed in the 1850 Census of Blackberry, Kane County, IL.
        David West’s home was “a stopping place of many of the stockmen who were enroute to Chicago, and he was also quite friendly with the Indians. . .” The Wests were considered an “honored pioneer family” in Kane County, IL. [46]

6. Hannah West b. 20 Jul 1796 [47]; d. 14 Jun 1856; buried at Concord Township Cemetery, Lake County, Ohio. [48]
        m. J.P. (John Peter) Oviatt [49]
        Children included Huldah Oviatt Burr, Maryette Oviatt Wilcox, Harriett Oviatt Hodges. [50] The Oviatt family was listed in the 1840 Census for Concord, Lake County, Ohio.

7. Edgar West b. 8 Jan 1798 [51]; d. 14 Jun 1883; buried at Concord Township Cemetery, Lake County, Ohio. [52]
        m. Margaret A. Wilson. [53]
        In the 1820 Census, Edgar West was living in Winchester, Litchfield County, CT with his wife and one child under ten years old. In the 1830 Census, Edgar West was in Concord, Geauga County, Ohio with his wife and five children. Edgar was the first sibling who moved to Ohio with his family.
        In the 1840 Census, Edgar West, his wife and eight children are listed in Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio. There is an elderly woman living with them. This is Mary West, who moved from Winsted, Connecticut in about 1836. [54]
        In Dec 1864, Edgar West was appointed to represent his district in a committee for the “Christmas Jubilee”—an event that gave donations to soldiers’ families (Union Army). [55] In Oct 1865, Edgar West was re-elected as a Justice of the Peace in Chardon. [56]
        In the 1880 Census of Chardon, Edgar is listed as a widower and is 81 years old.

8. Welthy or Wealthy West b. 18 May 1801 [57]
        m. 19 Jun 1822 Watrous T. Menter. [58] Menter is noted as an officer in the Chardon Grand Lodge (Masons) in Ohio (1842), with Hiram Wescott, who married Flora West. [59]

9. Flora West b. 1 Dec 1804 [60]; d. 17 Nov 1848; probably buried at Concord Township Cemetery, Lake County Ohio. [61]
        m. 29 Nov 1821 Hiram Wescott (b. 21 Dec 1798). [62] The 1830 Census lists them in Barkhamsted, Litchfield, CT. After Flora died, Hiram married (2) 2 Aug 1849 Hannah Hosford. [63]. Hiram and Hannah Hosford Wescott are buried together at Chardon Municipal Cemetery, Geauga County, OH. [64].


Timeline for Judah and Mary West
1790, 1800 and 1810. The Census of 1790 for Winchester, Litchfield, CT shows Judah and Mary, and two children. The Census of 1800 shows the growing family of eight children. The Census of 1810 has no listing for Judah and his family. They may have not been counted, or the records may have been lost. There is another possibility. Did they live in New York at that time?

In 1810, brother Aaron West was living in the region of Whitestown, Oneida County, New York. [65] Whitestown was located on a very large land patent belonging to investors securing a new frontier. These settlements were on the route to the Connecticut Western Reserve, a parcel that would become the future State of Ohio. [66]. Family tradition says that Aaron West was a lumberman, and moved from site to site clearing lands for settlement. [67] Perhaps Aaron invited Judah to join the venture. Aaron’s name was listed as “A. West” in the Oneida County Census of 1810. There are other Wests listed by initial—“P,” “W,” “Z” (or “T”) and two with the initial “J”. The listing for one “J. West” accounts for almost all of Judah and Mary’s children. However, the listing is not exactly correct, so we cannot take this as proof without more information. 

1818. In April 1818, Judah West applied for his Revolutionary War pension. He was living in Winsted (Winchester Township), Litchfield County, CT.

1820. Judah appeared in court in 1820, and provided an inventory of his possessions. This inventory is below, in the section, “Judah West’s Revolutionary War Pension Application.” In July of 1820, he began receiving 8 dollars per month (about $163 per year—$1,960 per year today). [68] In the Census of 1820, Judah and Mary are listed with two children. These would be Wealthy and Flora.

1825. Judah West died on 9 Apr 1825. He is buried at Winsted Old Burying Ground (Central Cemetery) in Winsted, Connecticut near his mother. [69] His marker reads:

In Memory of Judah West who died 9 April 1825 at 60 yrs
How sudden was the fatal stroke
When the Lord his summons spoke              
My friends & children now draw near
And see that you for death prepare.

1830. In the 1830 Census of Winchester, Litchfield, CT, Mary West is living by herself. Judah and Mary had been married about 40 years. Only Roswell and Nancy West Burr still remained in the area. The rest of her children had moved to New York and Ohio. Her son Edgar was the first to move to Geauga County, Ohio in the Connecticut Western Reserve, and eventually, others followed.

1836. Mary moved to Ohio in about 1836. [70]

1840. The Census of 1840 shows that Mary is living with her son Edgar West in Chardon, Geauga County, OH. 

1841. In 1841, Mary applied for the “widow’s pension.” She received $80 per year (about $2,100 today). [71] According to a contributor on the Findagrave Web site, Mary West married Alfred Tucker in 1841. Her tombstone says “Mary Tucker,” but I could find no verification of the date of their marriage.

1850. Mary’s tombstone at Concord Township Cemetery (Lake County, OH) says, “Mary Tucker, former wife of Judah West, 26 May 1850, age 86 years.” [72] Other family members buried there include Alpha and Anna West, Roswell and Nancy West Burr, John and Hannah West Oviatt, and Edgar and Margaret Wilson West.


Looking for the Link to Another West Family
West DNA Family Group #5 includes a variety of mystery ancestors, linked by DNA. The line of Judah West and another line, David West (b. 1758) of Dutchess and Genesee Counties, NY, share an interesting DNA similarity. The results say:

It appears likely that [the two modern day participants] are from the same branch of this family that either immigrated to the New England area, or moved there from the Virginia area before 1750. [The two participants] have values of 30 for the marker DYS 389-2, while everyone else in this group have values of 29. [73]

David West (b.1758) may have descended from Thomas West (b. 1630/1631) or his brother Henry West (b.1629) just like Judah West. Or, perhaps there was another male ancestor that has yet to be discovered. So far, the link between Judah West and his DNA cousin David West has not been determined.


References and Additional Notes
1. West DNA Family Group #5 results are at http://web.utk.edu/~corn/westdna/west5.htm#FG5.
2. Lorraine Cook White, editor, 1994-2002: The Lucius Barnes Barbour Collection of Connecticut Town Vital Records, Vol. 1-155, Genealogical Publishing Company, Baltimore, Maryland, “Chatham Vital Records,” p. 163. Also known as the Barbour Collection.
3. This was the location of the West family land in Middlesex County. Benjamin and Hannah West settled in the area in 1698. For more of this history please consult the article: http://westproj.blogspot.com/2014/07/benjamin-west-1665-1733.html
4. The other Judah West was born 4 Apr 1757 in Lebanon, New London County, CT. He was the son of Amos West and Sarah Cutter. Information comes from the Barbour Collection, “Lebanon Vital Records,” p. 223. He is very likely part of West DNA Family Group #19—descended from Francis West and Margery Reeves. For the listing of West DNA results go to: http://web.utk.edu/~corn/westdna/west5.htm.
5. Judah West, Private, Massachusetts Line, 1781-1783. Pension certificate No. 1020, 12 June 1818. Mary West (Widow’s Application) File No. W6451, 27 April 1841. National Archives and Records Administration, Washington, DC. Digital images on HeritageQuest.com. Accessed Dec 2013.
6. John Boyd, 1873:  Annals of Family Records of Winchester, Connecticut with Exercises of the Centennial Celebration, on the 16th and 17th Days of August, 1871, Case, Lockwood, and Brainard, Hartford, CT, p. 162.
7. Secretary of the Commonwealth, Massachusetts, 1896: Massachusetts Soldiers and Sailors of the Revolutionary War, Volume 16, Wright and Potter Printing, Boston, Massachusetts, p. 898.
8. History of Middlesex County, “Middletown in the Revolution,” p. 80. From the town meeting of 14 Apr 1772.
9. Henry P. Johnston, editor, 1889: “List of Revolutionary Pensioners—Connecticut,” The Record of Connecticut Men in the Military and Naval Service during the War of the Revolution, 1775-1783, The Adjutant-General of Connecticut, Hartford, CT, p. 637.
10. Robert K. Wright, Jr., 1983: The Continental Army, Center of Military History, United States Army, Washington, D.C., p. 207-210. Referenced as part of the Wikipedia entry, “Massachusetts Line.” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massachusetts_Line. Accessed December 2014.
11. Boyd, p. 289.
12. Boyd, p. 378.
13. Boyd, p. 297. Judah West’s cousin, Hopkins West, moved to Winchester at the same time. He later moved to Cambridge, NY. (Boyd, p. 157). Hopkins West was the son of Moses West and Sarah Hopkins.
14. Boyd, p. 289.
15. Barbour Collection, “Colebrook Vital Records 1779-1810,” p. 78 and 259. Also in Boyd, p. 289. In her widow’s pension application, Mary said the date was 15 Dec 1786.
16. Testimony of Elijah Rockwell, Jr. of Colebrook, and Lebinah and Martha Smith of Winchester, in Mary West’s application, 1841. Elijah Jr. remembered the wedding of Judah and Mary.
17. Hiram Wescott, 1821: “The Record of Judah West Family.” Page copied from Judah West’s handwriting into a Bible in 1821. This is on the inside front page of The New Testament of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, Translated Out of the Original Greek: and with the Former Translations Diligently Compared and Revised, W. Greenough Publishing (1820), Lunenburg, Massachusetts. Also referred to as “The Bible record.”
18. The written entry looks like “Bapet.” During this era, a stylized “p” generally indicated a double “s.”
19. Barbour Collection, “Winchester Vital Records 1771-1858,” p. 78. The Bible record says 1787.
20. Boyd, p. 385.
21. Boyd p. 325. Erastus, Halsey, and Roswell Burr were brothers in the scythe making trade (in Winchester).
22. Barbour Collection, “Winchester Vital Records 1771-1858,” p. 78. Both birth and death dates are from this source. The Bible record says 1790.
23. Barbour Collection, “Winchester Vital Records 1771-1858,” p. 78. The Bible record says 1791.
24. http://www.findagrave.com.
25. Ibid.
26. Unadilla Valley Historical Society, 1907: “Historical Sketches of Old Berlin,” by John Hyde (1876); Volume One, Transactions of the Unadilla Valley Historical Society, George H. Willard, New Berlin, New York, p. 92.
27. Beatrice West Seitz, 1971: West, Barker, Hodges; New York to Wisconsin 1836-1846. Self published, Janesville, Wisconsin, p. 12, 26, and others.
28. Barbour Collection, “Winchester Vital Records 1771-1858,” p. 78. The Bible record says 1793.
29. http://www.findagrave.com. The Burr ancestral family line is described in the entry.
30. Boyd, p. 385.
31. Ibid.
32. This is the date in the Bible record. Also, Henry Pierce, Arthur Merrill, and W.H. Perrin, compilers, 1878: The Past and Present of Kane County, Illinois, Wm Le Baron Jr. and Company, Chicago, Illinois, p. 618. Information is from the biographical entry for “G.C. West” of Blackberry.
33. http://www.findagrave.com. David West’s tombstone says he died at “85 years 1 Mo. 23 D’s.” He shares a tombstone with Rachel West, his second wife, who died at “81 years 2 M’s 5 D’s.”
34. Pierce et. al, p. 618. Dorothy’s birth, marriage, and death dates are in the entry for G.C. West.
35. Pictures of the Upper Phelps Cemetery are at http://www.findagrave.com. Dorothy “Dolly” Phelps West’s tombstone is surrounded by little tombstones for children of the Phelps and West families.
36. http://www.findagrave.com.
37. Pierce et. al, p. 618.
38. Copies of William P. West’s obituary and death certificate were posted by a descendant on ancestry.com. The death certificate lists David and Dolly West as William’s parents.
39. Pierce et. al, p. 618.
40. R. Waite Joslyn and Frank W. Joslyn, 1908: History of Kane County, Ill., Volume II, The Pioneer Publishing Co., Chicago, Illinois, p. 671. This is another brief biography of George C. West. It is noted that “He has in his possession some furniture which was used by his great-great-grandfather.” This would be Benjamin West, Jr. (1696-ca 1739) who lived in Middlesex County, CT.
41. Barbour Collection, “Litchfield Vital Records, 1719-1854,” p. 229.
42. http://www.findagrave.com.
43. Joslyn and Joslyn, p. 672.
44. Seitz, p. 12. In her examination of West land deed abstracts for her line, Seitz included the ones for David and Dorothy West. She could not figure out where David West fit into her line. 
GG, page 475—03 Sep 1823—David West, New Berlin and wife Dorothy West.
OO, pages 54, 55—06 Mar 1830—David West and wife Dolly, town of New Berlin, County of Chenango; witness Nathan Taylor.
00—15 May 1830—David West & Dolly, his wife to Lockhart W. Guile, New Berlin, #340, 28 and one-half acres of land, township 16.
PP, page 87—31 Aug 1830—David West, New Berlin & Wm. Conradt, Cortland, 10 acres for $35 township 20.
45. Pierce et. al, p. 618.
46. Joslyn and Joslyn, p. 672.
47. This is the date in the Bible record.
48. http://www.findagrave.com. “Hannah, wife of J.P. Oviatt, died June 14, 1787, aged 61 years.”
49. Boyd, p. 289.
50. http://www.findagrave.com.
51. This is the date in the Bible record.
52. http://www.findagrave.com. “Edgar West, Died June 14, 1883, Aged 84.” His tombstone has a Masonic symbol on it.
53. Boyd, p. 289.
54. Linus Wilson’s testimony in Mary West’s application. He testified in 1841: “I was well acquainted with them, and lived for many years a near neighbor, that since the decease of said Judah, and about five years ago, said Mary came to Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio.”
55. The Jeffersonian Democrat, Chardon, Ohio, December 9, 1864, page 3.
56. The Jeffersonian Democrat, Chardon, Ohio, October 13, 1865, page 3.
57. This is the date in the Bible record.
58. Barbour Collection, “Barkhamsted Vital Records 1779-1854,” p. 60. “West, Wealthy M. of Winchester, m. Watrous T. Menter, of Barkhamsted, June 19, 1822, by Saul Clark.”
59. Historical Society of Geauga County, 1880: Pioneer and General History of Geauga County: With Sketches of Some of the Pioneers and Prominent Men, Geauga County, Ohio, p. 82.
60. This is the date in the Bible record.
61. http://www.findagrave.com. There is no photo of Flora West’s tombstone.
62. Boyd, p. 289.
63.  Geauga County Genealogy Society, 1999: Geauga County Ohio, Marriages, 1806-1919 Grooms Index. Compiled for USGenWeb. http://files.usgwarchives.net/oh/geauga/vitals/marriages/grooms/w1.txt
64. Geauga County Genealogical Society, 2001: Geauga County Ohio: Chardon Village Cemetery Files. Compiled for USGenWeb. http://files.usgwarchives.net/oh/geauga/cemeteries/chv/alpha/atoz.txt. A picture of their tombstone is shown on http://www.findagrave.com.
65. Aaron West, Private, Connecticut Line, 1779-1782. Pension certificate No. 19607, Orwell, Oswego County, New York, 24 September 1832. Susanna West (Widow’s Application) File No. W19607, 7 December 1840. National Archives and Records Administration, Washington, DC. Digital images on HeritageQuest.com. Accessed Dec 2013. Please see the blog article on Aaron West at: http://westproj.blogspot.com/2014/11/aaron-west-1763-1840.html
66. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connecticut_Western_Reserve. Accessed Oct 2014.
67. Charles D. Fitzgerald, 1995: “Grandpa Was a Soldier . . . (But Never Fired a Shot at the Enemy!),” Heritage Quest, The International Genealogy Forum, Issue 60, November-December 1995, p. 17.
68. The inflation calculator that I used is at http://www.davemanuel.com/inflation-calculator.php. Accessed Nov 2014.
69. Charles R. Hale, compiler, 1916-1935: “Central Cemetery, Winsted,” The Charles R. Hale Collection of Connecticut Cemetery Inscriptions, Connecticut State Library, Hartford, Connecticut, p. 171. The tombstones of Judah and his mother can be found at http://www.findagrave.com.
70. Linus Wilson’s testimony. See Reference 54.
71. The inflation calculator that I used is at http://www.davemanuel.com/inflation-calculator.php. Accessed Nov 2014.
72. http://www.findagrave.com.
73. West DNA Family Group #5 results are at http://web.utk.edu/~corn/westdna/west5.htm#FG5.


Judah West’s Revolutionary War Pension Application

April 6, 1818
I Judah West of Winchester in the County of Litchfield and State of Connecticut depose and declare that in the month of August 1781 I enlisted as a Soldier in the Service of my Country in the Revolutionary war against the Common Enemy in the Company of a Capt. Smith in the Regmt of Col Jackson in the Massachusetts line and I joined the Army at West Point. I served about two years under Col. Jackson and the next part of the time under Col. Sprout. General Patterson Commanded the Brigade I Belonged to. I enlisted for three years and served faithfully until the Army was Disbanded and the war closed. Then I received my Discharge under the hand of General Knox dated the 23rd day of December 1783, which I send here with enclosed. I further Depose and Declare that I am poor and needy and have in need of the aid of my Country for Support. I am Fifty two years old and have a family. Judah West. (signature)

State of Connecticut to Litchfield County April 6th day 1818. Personally approved Judah West signer of the above affidavit and made solemn Oath to truth of the same before me. Augustus Pettibone, Chief Judge, Litchfield County Court. To: Hon John C. Calhoun, Secretary of War.

July 5, 1820
District of Connecticut, County of Litchfield, County Court on this 5 day of July 1820 personally appeared in open court, being a court of Record for said county in said district, having the power to fine and imprison Judah West aged 56 years resident in said county, who being first duly sworn according to law, doth on his oath declare that he served in the Revolutionary War as follows: He enlisted into the 8th Regiment Massachusetts line Michael or Henry Jackson Colonel, Capt Smith’s company, August 1781 and continued until the end of the War, and his discharge is to be found in the department of war, forwarded by him under his petition for a pension – that his original declaration was stated the 6th of April 1818 and that he received a pension certificate No. 1020.

. . .and I do solemnly swear that I was a resident citizen of the United States . . . and that I have not nor has any person in trust for me any property, or securities, contracts or debts due to me; nor have I income other than that what is contained in the schedule hereto annexed and by me subscribed, viz
$53.00   A life Estate in ___ of my wife of twenty acres of broken land lying in Winchester with a cottage & barn standing there on
42.00     2 Cows & ten sheep
3.00        1 hog
                10 Geese 5 Hens
1.75        1 Draught ___ one ax, 1 hoe
.75          1 Saw, 1 hammer 1 shave
3.50        8 chairs, ____ & ____
2.25        1 set andirons 2 old broken pots  - 2 kettles
.75          Tea Kettle dish Kettle 6 Knives and forks
3.00        2 old tables – 2 chairs
.35          1 looking glass small & old
2.00        1 wooden desk
1.00        And sundry other articles as jugs, basins, plates and tea cups & saucers not distinctly enumerated barely however sufficient for present necessity
$112.25
Judah (his mark) West

There is also a note in my name which is and always was the property of my son, being ___ of his own industry, for 100 dollars and dated 7 Sep 1815. Endorsed 10 Mar 1817. Thirty eight Dollars and 18 Nov 1817 Twelve dollars & 47 cents. There are honest debts against me of the amount one hundred and fifty dollars.

I am a man infirm: having had 2 shocks of palsy – but am able to do some labour. I am by occupation a laboring man. My family consists of my wife Mary West & two Daughters – my  wife is 58 years old, is infirm, & unable to labour much & one of my daughters is 17 years of age, the other fifteen & dependent on me for support. Judah (his mark) West

Court agreed that the total value of the property was $112.25, 17 Jul 1820.

c/o Hon John L. Calhoun, Secretary of War.